Jessica Woodville | Memoir & Musings

Why Trauma-Informed Care Is Essential for Effective Mental Health Treatment

The Problem with Mental Health Diagnoses & Trauma

When I first sought help, I was handed a mental health questionnaire—not a conversation.
Boxes were checked. Labels assigned. Medications prescribed.

But no one asked the question that could have changed everything:
“What happened to you?”

This is the core issue in modern mental health care: we treat symptoms without seeking the story behind them. We medicate before we understand. We diagnose before we connect.

In this post, I’ll share what I wish every therapist, psychiatrist, and mental health professional knew about trauma-informed care—and how we can do better for survivors.

---

1. Trauma Affects the Entire Body—Not Just the Mind

Trauma isn’t just emotional—it’s physiological. It embeds itself in the nervous system, the immune system, even the gut.

Trauma’s Physical Effects Include:

• Nervous System Dysregulation: Chronic fight-or-flight activation
• Adrenal Dysfunction & Fatigue: Hormonal imbalance from prolonged stress
• Autoimmune & Inflammatory Disorders: Higher risk of chronic illness
• Digestive Problems: IBS, leaky gut, food sensitivities

Yet many mental health professionals still focus solely on psychological symptoms like depression, anxiety, or ADHD—missing the deeply rooted physical toll trauma takes.

What Helps Instead:

• Holistic Trauma Care that includes:
  • Somatic therapies (EMDR, Polyvagal Theory, bodywork)
  • Nervous system regulation
  • Medical screenings for trauma-related conditions

---

2. High ACE Scores Should Be Part of Mental Health Assessments

The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study showed that early trauma increases the risk of:

• Depression, PTSD, and anxiety
• Chronic illness, fatigue, autoimmune disorders
• A shortened lifespan—by up to 20 years

And yet, most therapists and psychiatrists don’t screen for ACE scores.

If a patient has a high ACE score, traditional methods like CBT may not be enough. These survivors often need bottom-up, nervous system-first approaches.

What Helps Instead:

• Include ACE score assessments in intake forms
• Make trauma education standard in clinical training programs

---

3. Trauma Responses Are Often Misdiagnosed as Mental Illness

Trauma doesn’t always show up as flashbacks. Sometimes it looks like emotional dysregulation, exhaustion, or dissociation. And too often, these responses are misdiagnosed:

Trauma Response	Common Misdiagnosis
Emotional dysregulation	Bipolar disorder
Hypervigilance	Generalized anxiety disorder
Dissociation	ADHD or personality disorder
Chronic fatigue & pain	Somatic symptom disorder
Depression-like symptoms	Major depressive disorder

This leads to inappropriate treatments, overmedication, and prolonged suffering.

What Helps Instead:

• Ask about trauma history before diagnosing
• Understand that trauma can look like many things—but it’s not always mental illness

---

4. “Trauma-Informed” Should Be More Than a Buzzword

Plenty of professionals use the phrase “trauma-informed,” but their methods don’t match.

What Trauma-Informed Care Is Not:

• ❌ Using CBT as a one-size-fits-all approach
• ❌ Prescribing medication without considering nervous system dysregulation
• ❌ Labeling patients as “resistant” when they struggle with traditional therapy

What Trauma-Informed Care Is:

• ✅ Recognizing nervous system dysregulation
• ✅ Offering body-based approaches like EMDR, somatic experiencing, and breathwork
• ✅ Seeing patients as whole people—not just symptom lists

---

5. “Do You Feel Safe?” Should Go Beyond Physical Safety

One of the most healing moments in my journey was when a nurse practitioner asked me, “Do you feel safe?”

But for trauma survivors, safety is about far more than physical protection.
It means:

• Emotional safety: Feeling validated, not gaslit
• Psychological safety: Being believed and understood
• Environmental safety: Having stability at home, work, and in relationships

Too often, survivors are dismissed because their wounds are invisible.

What Helps Instead:

• Redefine “safety” to include emotional and psychological well-being
• Train clinicians to recognize hidden trauma responses

---

6. Medication Should Not Be the First Line of Treatment

I’m not anti-medication. But I am against using it as the default.

Here’s why:

• SSRIs made me physically sick—my nervous system was already overstimulated
• Stimulants worsened my symptoms—my body was stuck in fight-or-flight
• Benzodiazepines numbed me—but didn’t heal the root of the pain

What Helps Instead:

• ✅ Somatic therapy (breathwork, grounding, vagus nerve work)
• ✅ Nervous system regulation (movement, cold exposure, trauma-informed yoga)
• ✅ Targeted trauma therapy (EMDR, ART, somatic experiencing)

Medication can be helpful—but it should come after understanding the nervous system.

---

7. Healing Trauma Requires More Than Just Talk Therapy

Many believe therapy is the solution. But for survivors, healing is multi-layered.

It’s not just about revisiting the past—it’s about rebuilding the future.

True healing includes:

• Physical healing: Nervous system regulation
• Mental healing: Understanding trauma responses
• Emotional healing: Processing grief and suppressed emotion
• Spiritual healing: Rediscovering meaning and connection

For me, healing has looked like:
✨ Learning how trauma reshaped my brain and body
✨ Finding alternative therapies when traditional ones failed
✨ Building a trauma-informed support system

Healing is not just about talking. It’s about transforming.

---

A Call for Trauma-Informed Change

Mental health professionals don’t need to have all the answers. But they do need to start asking better questions.

• Stop treating trauma like just another mental illness
• Start screening for ACE scores as part of every intake
• Integrate nervous system work into treatment plans
• Make trauma education mandatory in psychiatric and therapy training

Because survivors aren’t broken.
The system that ignores trauma is.
And it’s time for change.

---

Want to learn more about trauma recovery, ACEs, or trauma-informed resources?
Visit my Resources Page for books, studies, and expert insights.

If this post resonates with you, please share it.
Let’s make trauma-informed care the standard, not the exception.